Governor Gavin Newsom of California has made headlines recently for legislation that will make some 80,000 diesel-powered trucks illegal in January and prevent the sale of gas-powered cars in 2035. Despite these aggressive tactics, U.S. carbon emissions have fallen drastically since 2007. “Pro-environmental” legislation, coupled with devastating heat waves, have caused a long-predicted energy shortage for the state.
NATIONAL REVIEW: The Left’s Power Shortage
The Editors; September 12, 2022
It’s one of the many internal contradictions of modern environmentalism that proponents want more things to be powered by electricity while also wanting to make it harder to generate electricity. There’s hardly a better demonstration of that contradiction than California public utilities’ advising their customers not to charge their vehicles during certain hours of the day when electricity supply will run low. Gas stations start to look pretty attractive to drivers, even if prices are high, if they can at least guarantee the ability to drive at any time.
But California is set to deny its residents that option, with the sale of new gasoline-powered cars to be banned by 2035. In addition, the state is slowly banning diesel-powered trucks, with an estimated 80,000 trucks becoming illegal overnight on January 1 for having engines that were built before 2010. That will ratchet up in stages every few years, eventually culminating in a total ban.
Forcing more dependence on a brittle system is harmful both to California residents and to the companies running the electric grid, but it’s the direction California politicians have decided to go, and they don’t seem to be swayed by recent events.
Governor Newsom sees this energy shortage as “just the latest reminder of how real the climate crisis is.” He said that it “reinforces the need for urgent action to end our dependence on fossil fuels that are destroying our climate and making these heat waves hotter and more common.”
Yet the United States as a whole continues to reduce its carbon-dioxide emissions, which have been trending downward since 2007 (no matter who’s president). Also, plenty of other states have experienced heat waves, and they’ve managed to do so without the specter of blackouts.
According to the Biden administration, California is doing great. Secretary of Energy Jennifer Granholm said that the state “shaped our willingness in the federal government to move further and faster” — just four days before some residents experienced blackouts. She called California’s energy policy “unabashedly bold.”
It’s bold all right, in much the same way that forfeiting a championship dodgeball match would be a bold strategy to win. While the good guys do end up winning in the movies, real life isn’t Hollywood, and happy endings aren’t guaranteed. Progressives often pat themselves on the back for their boldness, with little regard given to the consequences of the policies they propose.
Electricity shortages in California were not only predictable; they were predicted. The closure of one of the state’s nuclear plants cost California 2.2 gigawatts of electricity, enough to power 1.65 million homes. Both government and non-government energy experts have warned of shortages for years.
Yet California persisted in its self-destructive energy policy. And now residents are paying the price. If the state doesn’t change its ways, this will be far from the last electricity shortage in California.
The state’s approach does not make sense even if we grant the catastrophic-alarmist interpretation of climate change in full. California accounts for a tiny fraction of the world’s carbon emissions. California’s zeroing out its carbon emissions wouldn’t create a climate-change-free zone in California airspace.
Of course, the state hopes to leverage its influence beyond its borders, which makes its policies more than just a California problem. As the state with the largest population and the largest economy, California regulations can become de facto nationwide standards. And sometimes they are even legally binding in other states, which have signed on to California’s policies in their own jurisdictions. Virginia is one of those states, and Governor Glenn Youngkin is calling on state legislators to repeal the law. Youngkin is correct, and we hope Virginia can start a trend of states moving away from these destructive regulations.
Forcing citizens to become ever more reliant on electricity that isn’t forthcoming isn’t only poor governance or inept management. These policies are the fruit of a radical progressive ideology that sees human beings as burdens and prosperity as blight. Republicans must make clear to voters that California’s woes are a direct result of unified Democratic governance, and that those woes could be arriving upon other states should voters choose to empower the same political party beholden to the same radical-environmentalist interests.
Photo: Justin Sullivan/Getty Images